Skip to content
The Lost Coffee Mug The Lost Coffee Mug

  • Home
  • Books
    • Audiobook Reviews
    • Book Reviews
    • Bookish News
  • Contact
The Lost Coffee Mug
The Lost Coffee Mug

August 14, 2025

Audiobook Review – ‘Fake As Puck’ by Sarah Smith

‘Fake As Puck’ by Sarah Smith
Narrator/Narrators:
 Shiloh James, Tim Paige 
Series: Denver Bashers Series #1 
Published: March 25, 2025 
Genre: Romance, Sports Romance 
Format: Audiobook 
Spice Level: 🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️
Stars: ⭐⭐1/2
Narration: 🎤🎤

When I was reading what Fake As Puck was about, I was super excited.  I felt like this was going to be a great book.  I am said to say the hyper I was giving to myself did not go well.  I am not sure if the writing of the characters is what threw me off or what.  I have to say the characters in the book felt a little immature.  But I will say that when it came to the big thing that happened, they did act mature in figuring out what happened and how to move on from what happened. That was a huge surprise for me.

Fake As Puck was an audiobook to me, and had Shiloh James and Tim Paige as the narrators.  They did an okay job giving this audiobook two microphones.  I felt like some of the narration could be better, and I wasn’t feeling the characters come alive like how some audiobooks I listen to.

With everything I have said, and who knows, maybe it is due to the narration of the story I am giving Fake as Puck two and a half stars.  Like I said, how they handled the issue that came up was handled so well, but up to that point, this book was just not there and felt off. There was spice in this book… when I say spice, I mean a good chunk of spice. The spice level is four chili peppers. 

If you like hockey and enjoy spice, this book might be it for you. Just because I didn’t enjoy it doesn’t mean you won’t.  And if you are a Kindle Unlimited member, the e-book version of this book is included in your membership.

I would like to thank Love Note PR for the ALC Copy of this book.  Getting the ALC Copy did not influence my thoughts on the book as they are all my own.

Book Reviews Books 2 1/2 Stars2 MicrophonesAudiobookDenver Bashers SeriesFake As PuckKindle UnlimitedNew ReleaseRomanceSarah SmithShiloh JamesSpice Level 4 Chili PeppersSports RomanceTim Paige

Post navigation

Previous post

Related Posts

Audiobook Reviews

Audiobook Review – ‘Hudson’ by Samantha Skye

July 25, 2025July 25, 2025

‘Hudson’ by Samantha Skye Narrator/Narrators: Amanda Stribling & Patrick Zeller  Series: The Billionaires of Whispers #2…

Read More
Book Reviews

Book Review – ‘Broken Play’ by Riley Paige

July 17, 2025July 17, 2025

‘Broken Play’ by Riley PageSeries: PCU Storm #1 Published: June 5, 2025 Genre: Romance, Sports Romance Format: e-book Spice Level: 🌶️🌶️🌶️Stars: ⭐⭐⭐ 1/2 Riley Paige…

Read More
Book Reviews

Book Review – ‘Pregnant Before “I Do”’ by Bella Mason

August 9, 2025

‘Pregnant Before “I Do”’ by Bella MasonSeries: The De Luca Legacy #2Published: July 1, 2025Genre:…

Read More

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

©2025 The Lost Coffee Mug | WordPress Theme by SuperbThemes